Essential concepts to embrace and discard to understand China
Editor's note: Daryl Guppy is an international financial technical analysis expert. He has provided weekly Shanghai Index analysis for media for the Chinese mainland for more than a decade. Guppy appears regularly on CNBC Asia and is known as "The Chart Man." He is a national board member of the Australia China Business Council. The article reflects the author's opinions, and not necessarily the views of CGTN.
"We must pay attention to a good grasp of the tone, as well as be open, confident and humble, try our utmost to portray an image of a reliable, lovely, respectable China," President Xi Jinping said recently. Many Westerners welcomed this because they believe China should be submissive, but Western attitudes must also change.
Passport, COVID-19 vaccination certificate, and visa are the three essential items travelers routinely check before traveling to China. Travelers also need to check their intellectual baggage. In seeking to understand China, it is essential to discard two concepts and embrace a third.
The first discarded concept is the notion that the Chinese government is somehow not legitimate because it does not match the democratic norms prevailing in Western countries. For many people, including political leaders, this is a difficult notion to discard, because they are convinced that the democratic system is the only legitimate form of government.
They are happy to overlook the undemocratic kingdoms in the Middle East, Thailand and other jurisdictions as these countries serve the interests of the West. However, they remain deeply opposed to the system of governance in China.
Although not openly advocating regime change, a number of Western powers are very critical of China's system of government. They believe only democratically elected governments can be legitimate. Australia's former Foreign Minister Julie Bishop believes China has no legitimate right to call for changes to the global rules based order because China does not fit the democratic model.
This notion ignores the deep levels of popular support for the Chinese government. If one of the governments' prime responsibilities is to increase the prosperity of its people and to eliminate poverty then by these measures alone, the Chinese government has earned its support and legitimacy.
In the last 30 or more years, the Chinese leadership has delivered a stable, secure and prosperous society. It is a governance that draws on the deep traditions of Chinese civilization and delivers results which validate the legitimacy of and support for government. Every year around 155 million tourists leave China, yet foreign embassies are not besieged by Chinese nationals seeking asylum. As much as some in the West suggest there is significant internal discontent in China, these behaviors belie their assertions.
Of course not every policy decision is universally accepted. In a population of 1.4 billion, you will always find dissenters. The United States, with a population of just 331 million, has dissenters who violently stormed the White House.
The second concept for Western leaders to discard is the idea that prosperity is dependent upon democracy. The evangelists of democracy believed that as China grew more prosperous, it would inevitably adopt a democratic structure. It took more than 20 years for these evangelists to realize this was not going to happen and their bitter disappointment colors today's foreign policy decisions.
Singapore, with its quasi-democracy, shows that the path to prosperity is more nuanced. China shows there are other paths to prosperity. India has taken a slower and more tortuous path and their results show that democracy alone is not sufficient to deliver even moderate prosperity.
Discarding these two political prescriptions and preferences will allow Western travelers to acknowledge the legitimacy of the Chinese government so they can concentrate on how prosperity can be maintained and grown for all.
The third essential and new concept for the informed traveler is to embrace the concept of scale. First-time visitors to China are overwhelmed by the sheer size of China and its achievements. The 38,000 kilometers of high-speed rail compared with virtually none in the United States is but one example. The governance of 1.4 billion people is a task of a different order of magnitude than the governance of 331 million people in the United States, or a paltry 25.5 million in Australia.
The management of scale calls for different approaches and methods. The nearest comparison in terms of population is India. With its crumbling infrastructure, desperate poverty, illiteracy and religious division, India provides no shining alternative approach.
China has developed its own unique solutions to governance and they draw on centuries of tradition. The solutions are different to those developed in the United States and European countries but the solutions are no less legitimate.
The elimination of poverty and the development of a moderately prosperous society on a scale not seen before in human history is cause for praise. The essentials of any successful China relationship rests on discarding outdated concepts and accepting legitimate solutions which have overwhelming support from people living in China. Western leaders need to recognize which concepts to discard and which to embrace, when developing a China engagement policy that is appropriate and effective.
A good grasp of tone matters for all participants.
(If you want to contribute and have specific expertise, please contact us at opinions@cgtn.com.)
相关阅读
-
澳洲学者:对美国唯命是从的澳大利亚也难逃“美国优先”大棒砸下
澳大利亚长期讨好美国,希望以此免受“美国优先”政策冲击,一边继续享受美国的安全保护,一边维持正常的澳中、澳美贸易关系。但近期特朗普的一系列离谱言行表明,这种期望可能只是幻想。
-
澳洲学者:美国说什么“强化供应链”,到头来还是为打压中国
近日,“印太经济框架” (IPEF) 下的供应链协议生效。事实上,IPEF是美国对华战略竞争的地缘政治工具,它利用其他成员国寻求供应链多元化的本意,完全以美国自身利益和战略目标为出发点,旨在围堵、遏制中国经济。
-
澳专家:G7广岛峰会嘴上说的都是“秩序”,心里想的都是“霸权”
今年七国集团 (G7) 峰会在日本广岛举办,首要议程仍是维护霸权秩序。广岛是第一个遭到核武器袭击摧毁的城市,这一会议地点和G7不断变化的关注焦点相结合,讽刺意味浓烈。G7的成立主要是为了促进共同的宏观经济倡议,以应对当代经济问题,但现在它正蓄势发起经济战。
-
Australia's adversarial China policy
Daryl Guppy is an international financial technical analysis expert. He has provided weekly Shanghai Index analysis for Chinese mainland media for more than a decade. Guppy appears regularly on CNBC Asia and is known as "The Chart Man."
-
China stock market opportunity
Daryl Guppy is an international financial technical analysis expert. He has provided weekly Shanghai Index analysis for Chinese mainland media for more than a decade. Guppy appears regularly on CNBC Asia and is known as "The Chart Man." He is a national board member of the Australia China Business Council. The article reflects the author's opinions and not necessarily the views of CGTN.
-
G7 blue dots or BRI red spots?
Editor's note: Daryl Guppy is an international financial technical analysis expert. He has provided weekly Shanghai Index analysis for Chinese mainland media for more than a decade.
-
Australia on a 'mission to provoke imperial resurrection'
Daryl Guppy is an international financial technical analysis expert. He has provided weekly Shanghai Index analysis for Chinese mainland media for more than a decade.
-
Australia pines for the past
Editor's note: Daryl Guppy is an international financial technical analysis expert and special consultant to AxiCorp. He has provided weekly Shanghai Index analysis for media for the Chinese mainland for more than a decade. Guppy appears regularly on CNBC Asia and is known as "The Chart Man." He is a national board member of the Australia China Business Council. The article reflects the author's opinions and not necessarily the views of CGTN.
免责声明:本网所发所有文章,包括本网原创、编译及转发的第三方稿件及评论,均不构成任何投资建议,交易操作或投资决定请询问专业人士。
热门点击
-
- 纽约商品交易所(COMEX)铜价逼近历史高位 铜市最著名多头预言家预测铜价涨至1.2-1.3万美元/吨
-
- 【3.31】今日财经时讯及重要市场资讯
-
- 传闻赤峰黄金参与昆州Ravenswood金矿第二轮竞标
-
- 生活成本(Cost of Living)再度成为选民重要考量因素 工党、自由党纷纷发声
-
- 澳洲两大超市盈利能力位居全球前列 市场主导地位难以撼动
-
- 澳交所上市石墨电极材料技术公司NOVONIX Limited ( ASX: NVX)获批在购买土地 拟在美国建造大型合成石墨生产基地 深耕欧美电极材料市场
-
- 【澳洲大选动态】 彼得·达顿(Peter Dutton)领导的自由党联盟承诺: 若胜选将向昆士兰州华人博物馆提供22.5万澳元资助
-
- 新南威尔士州发现含致命尼塔佐酮的伪造药物 卫生部门发布紧急警告
-
- 去年销售收入2760万元 最新季报显示现金头寸2060万元 肺部医疗成像技术公司Cyclopharm Limited (ASX: CYC) 产品进入美国市场 潜力初现
-
- 重卡货运:支撑澳出口和国内物流贸易的重要产业 机遇面前面临碳减排和电气化两大挑战
-
- Larvotto Resources (ASX: LRV)加速推进澳洲最大锑矿项目开发 中国实施锑出口管控后股价涨幅逾十倍
-
- 多头发力 COMEX期铜连续两日改写历史新高!
-
- Emvision Medical Devices(ASX:EMV)完成中风脑损伤便捷检测仪航空医学概念验证测试
-
- FMG股价一年跌幅近40% 瑞银认为或存在超卖现象
-
- 对冲基金看淡澳元 加大空头头寸