Australia's adversarial China policy
Australia Treasurer Josh Frydenberg reacts during Question Time in the House of Representatives at Parliament House in Canberra, Australia, June 22, 2021. /Getty
Editor's note: Daryl Guppy is an international financial technical analysis expert. He has provided weekly Shanghai Index analysis for Chinese mainland media for more than a decade. Guppy appears regularly on CNBC Asia and is known as "The Chart Man." He is a national board member of the Australia China Business Council. The article reflects the author's opinions and not necessarily the views of CGTN.
On September 6, Australian Treasurer Josh Frydenberg gave a speech to urge his nation of firm stance against China with the background celebrating 70 years of the Australia, New Zealand and the United States (ANZUS) defense treaty between the three countries. Australia has been somewhat desperate to show how good a friend it has been to the United States, even if the United States has not always reciprocated in full.
Frydenberg used the state of the Australian economy as evidence that Australia had successfully withstood the impacts of Chinese trade restrictions. It's certainly true that some Australian industries have been able to find substitute markets for those lost in China. It's equally true that many businesses have not been able to find substitutes.
In his rush to highlight Australia's economic resilience, Frydenberg neglected to mention how the United States – the good friend ANZUS partner – has quickly stepped into the void left by Australian industries in China. U.S. beef exports were an almost perfect replacement for the tonnage lost by Australia due to trade restrictions.
The idea of standing shoulder to shoulder with our best friends doesn't seem to have the same cachet in the United States.
Frydenberg used this leadership address as an opportunity to berate China and highlight how China's combination of economic strength and global integration "poses new and significant challenges for many countries." He said Australia is "on the frontline" of growing strategic competition between China and the U.S. He describes China as "more confident and assertive" and called this "a defining feature of the economic and security landscape we face."
Despite a government wish that this view represents a united Australian front, it is a view that does not enjoy unqualified support from business or from those who are attuned to a more nuanced view of the change that is taking place in the region.
Just days prior to Frydenberg's speech former Prime Minister Paul Keating said "the Morrison government is wantonly leading Australia into a strategic dead end by its needless provocations against China."
A Chinese national flag flies outside the Chinese Embassy in Canberra, Australia, May 10, 2021. /Getty
David Olsson, president of Australia's peak China business body, the Australia China Business Council said, "We encourage China to focus on the complementarities of the relationship and view the relationship as one of opportunity, rather than threat or uncertainty."
Stoked by a mixture of attitudes derived from U.S. bible-belt fanaticism, a well-coordinated campaign of foreign influence through think tanks funded by the U.S. and the UK arms manufacturers and the mistaken idea that China is an expansionist state like the old Soviet Union, the Australian government has become hostage to a particular brand of reworked imperialism.
In June, Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison encouraged European naval fleets to visit the South China Sea in a dangerous exercise of saber rattling. Morrison expected China to obey the decisions and rules adopted by the G7.
It's a body of thought that is astounded that China has the temerity to challenge the primacy of the United States and to even suggest that China should play an increased role in setting the rules that form the basis of the global order.
It's a body of thought that seeks to deny China's place in the world and to condemn as unacceptable Chinese aspirations for improved living standards.
Keating said, "China's great problem is that it is now a state as large as the United States, and with the potential of being much larger – an unforgivable sin for American triumphalist."
Until recently, Australian business has largely kept quiet about their increasing concerns around the ramped up rhetoric in the hope that it would prove to be a passing phase. Business leaders and others have become increasingly concerned about the impact of this approach not only on Australia's trade with China, but Australia's relationship with the region.
Treasurer Frydenberg suggests Australia can benefit from a China plus strategy. It's a sound approach for any trade-dependent economy but it does not have to rest on the vilification of China. That's a message that he hopes will play well to Australia's U.S. friends but it does little to assist with engagement with China. Just as importantly, this China-bashing does not sit well with Australia's other trade partners in the region. They generally have a far more complex relationship and sophisticated understanding about China and their trade with China.
Frydenberg's attitude and comments are designed to curry favor with the United States. They reflect a wishful economic thinking where the true economic impact of Australia's poor relations with China have been masked by Australia's fairy-tale COVID-19 economic resilience, supported ironically, by Chinese demand for iron ore and coal.
(If you want to contribute and have specific expertise, please contact us at opinions@cgtn.com.)
相关阅读
-
澳洲学者:对美国唯命是从的澳大利亚也难逃“美国优先”大棒砸下
澳大利亚长期讨好美国,希望以此免受“美国优先”政策冲击,一边继续享受美国的安全保护,一边维持正常的澳中、澳美贸易关系。但近期特朗普的一系列离谱言行表明,这种期望可能只是幻想。
-
澳洲学者:美国说什么“强化供应链”,到头来还是为打压中国
近日,“印太经济框架” (IPEF) 下的供应链协议生效。事实上,IPEF是美国对华战略竞争的地缘政治工具,它利用其他成员国寻求供应链多元化的本意,完全以美国自身利益和战略目标为出发点,旨在围堵、遏制中国经济。
-
澳专家:G7广岛峰会嘴上说的都是“秩序”,心里想的都是“霸权”
今年七国集团 (G7) 峰会在日本广岛举办,首要议程仍是维护霸权秩序。广岛是第一个遭到核武器袭击摧毁的城市,这一会议地点和G7不断变化的关注焦点相结合,讽刺意味浓烈。G7的成立主要是为了促进共同的宏观经济倡议,以应对当代经济问题,但现在它正蓄势发起经济战。
-
China stock market opportunity
Daryl Guppy is an international financial technical analysis expert. He has provided weekly Shanghai Index analysis for Chinese mainland media for more than a decade. Guppy appears regularly on CNBC Asia and is known as "The Chart Man." He is a national board member of the Australia China Business Council. The article reflects the author's opinions and not necessarily the views of CGTN.
-
G7 blue dots or BRI red spots?
Editor's note: Daryl Guppy is an international financial technical analysis expert. He has provided weekly Shanghai Index analysis for Chinese mainland media for more than a decade.
-
Australia on a 'mission to provoke imperial resurrection'
Daryl Guppy is an international financial technical analysis expert. He has provided weekly Shanghai Index analysis for Chinese mainland media for more than a decade.
-
Australia pines for the past
Editor's note: Daryl Guppy is an international financial technical analysis expert and special consultant to AxiCorp. He has provided weekly Shanghai Index analysis for media for the Chinese mainland for more than a decade. Guppy appears regularly on CNBC Asia and is known as "The Chart Man." He is a national board member of the Australia China Business Council. The article reflects the author's opinions and not necessarily the views of CGTN.
-
Essential concepts to embrace and discard to understand China
Editor's note: Daryl Guppy is an international financial technical analysis expert. He has provided weekly Shanghai Index analysis for media for the Chinese mainland for more than a decade. Guppy appears regularly on CNBC Asia and is known as "The Chart Man." He is a national board member of the Australia China Business Council. The article reflects the author's opinions, and not necessarily the views of CGTN.
免责声明:本网所发所有文章,包括本网原创、编译及转发的第三方稿件及评论,均不构成任何投资建议,交易操作或投资决定请询问专业人士。
热门点击
-
- 比特币回报率完胜股票远超大宗商品 波动率下行是否意味暴涨时代终结?
-
- 黄金板块艳压群雄年度涨幅逾五成 “黄金再次货币化”驱动估值重塑浪 个股表现或现分化
-
- 【7.7】今日财经时讯及重要市场资讯
-
- 【7.8】今日财经时讯及重要市场资讯
-
- 与香港股东分道扬镳?Star Entertainment(ASX:SGR)或于明年失去皇后码头赌场经营权
-
- 假冒本土清仓实为海外发货 四家“幽灵商店”遭ACCC曝光
-
- 与香港股东分道扬镳?Star Entertainment(ASX:SGR)或于明年失去皇后码头赌场经营权
-
- 【7.9】今日财经时讯及重要市场资讯
-
- Barrenjoey持续看好澳交所热门铀矿股:供需失衡支撑铀价长期上涨
-
- 澳洲商业地产市场显著复苏 分析称受益于降息及美关税政策
-
- 警惕针对“海归”人才的四种论调
-
- 美元半年贬值逾10% 澳洲人去哪些国家旅游“更划算”?
-
- 【异动股】两日暴涨3倍!能源公司Energy World Corporation (ASX:EWC)公司控股权变更管理层换帅
-
- 黄金资源量610万盎司 市值1.19亿澳元 Theta Gold Mines(ASX:TGM)旗舰项目采矿决策通过 优质资产有望迎来重大重估
-
- 【异动股】电信公司Vonex (ASX:VN8) 面临MaxoTel收购 股价暴涨94.44%